Wikipedia is all well and good, but it has weaknesses, as each should be clear. Currently, I was on the wikipedia article " abuse with abuse 'attention. It says: " According to the President of the German family court day, Siegfried Willutzki, is elevated to about 40% of all contested custody cases through the fighting for custody of mother accused of sexual abuse against the father. "This data is based on an article in the Rheinische Post, 26.3.1994, there are several Internet references to this passage. In particular, "Väterrechtler" wie z.B. die paPPas, „Väter für Kinder“, „Väteraufbruch für Kinder“ aber auch Homepages der Maskulistenbewegung etc. verweisen immer wieder auf diese Quelle. Diese belege das hohe Ausmass von willentlichen Falschbeschuldigungen gegen Väter, um diese zu zerstören und um vor allem den Kontakt zum Kind zu unterbinden, so der Tenor dieser “Männeraktivisten“. Da die Ermittlungsverfahren wegen sexuellen Missbrauchs im Folgejahr nach 1994 zugenommen hätten, schreiben z.B. die paPPas auf ihrer Homepage: " In der Konsequenz hat also ein Vater, der gerichtlich um Sorge oder Umgang streitet, eine 1:1-Chance, sich den Vorwurf einzuhandeln ."
Zu dem Thema an sich can now write a whole book, so much hair-raising and richtigzustellendes material (also produced by reputable media as the mirror - by Gisela Friedrichsen - and time - by Sabine Rückert) is therefore now available. Since my blog has a very good Googel positioning, I like to take this opportunity to write in my humble limits of the capacity on the above numbers something.
When one realizes that, for example, it was decided in 1996 over 150,000 cases in the matters of parental care and in over 20,000 cases on the question of a policy (see Ruhl, R. 2000: Fathers - sacrifice in separation and divorce ? In: Lenz, H.-J. (Ed.): Male victims experience. Problems and help approaches in the men's advice. Juventa, Weinheim. , P. 150) that would make sexual 40% 60 000 reported cases of abuse in custody disputes and 8,000 reported cases during handling disputes. 1996 but only 19 522 cases of sexual abuse were registered by the police and these cases relate to mind a variety of groups of perpetrators, not only to fathers. The figure of 40% can thus be alone through this small statement refuted very easily. But we are adding this still a study
bus / controller / Volbert (2000), Berlin 1394 files Family courts on the issue of parental access from the vintages 1988, 1993 and 1995 evaluated scientifically. In only 45 cases (about 3.3%) there was a suspicion of sexual abuse of language. An analysis of 1,500 custody records from the three cohorts also yielded only 45 cases (3.0%) that include a suspicion of abuse. (See Bange, D., Körner, W. 2002. Handwörterbuch Sexual Abuse Hogrefe-Verlag, p. 94)
Another example calculation brings us closer to reality again:
1996, only 1543 of the 19 526 (suspected) victims with the perpetrators, the perpetrator used. This represents 7.90% of the cases. (See Federal Ministry of the Interior / Federal Ministry of Justice, 2006: Second Periodic Safety Report . P. 101) Approx. 3.5% of the suspects are also female, the statistics show (dark field studies show something else, but only incidentally). As this text to the (alleged mass) false accusation made against men and especially fathers, refers so again we can deduct 3.5% from the 1543 "family" cases, which would be minus 54th Stay 1489 charges against men who are related to the (alleged) victim. Now man must know also that, for example in 1999, 24.5% of all suspects were 8-21 years old, So usually have no own children. And 8.1% of the suspects were over 60 years old and fall out in disputes regarding custody. I suspect however, that appear within the "family" cases more suspects over 21 years. In this respect, I draw again conservative 10% of the 1489 ads against male relatives. What remains are still 1340 cases. Within these remaining cases are now stuck not only fathers but also uncle, possibly a cousin by marriage, or the stepfather, perhaps a couple of young grandfathers who have over 60-year-old suspect above we already expected something out. How many physical Fathers were viewed, so is speculation. To get an even number, I expect just with high 1.000. I think this honestly say that there are far fewer. But we just stay at that number
Let's return to the 150,000 custody cases from 1996 and make these cases easy all 1,000 possible charges against fathers to (although ads made against fathers even outside of custody disputes). That would mean then that is pronounced in only 0.66% of custody cases, a suspicion of abuse against fathers!
(The Berlin study of bus / controller / Volbert (2000) had shown to the 3%. This suggests the conclusion suggest that there is a separate regional display behavior and is especially large cities appear relatively much.)
The police crime statistics over recent years also shows that lead from the indicated cases, only about 10% to a conviction. From the above calculated fictional fathers are doomed in 1000 only 100 (most of them on probation or a fine, even showing the statistics). The courts act so very very careful here and not send masses of fathers in the prisons because their crazy (which is under hypnosis feminist) EX-wives even "just" saying any suspected abuse to to secure custody.
haunted Despite these data easy to find out the number of 40% of allegations against fathers on the internet around, even on wikipedia. The relevant question (Internet) players have to leave my opinion, what motivation they have to spread such a wrong number? (Actually, should have the information even be in the interests of fathers activists to calm alone have their own nervous about the true ratios.)
This whole issue about alleged massive false accusations and countless "bad mothers" and "vindictive feminists" is an issue with innumerable Abysses. Here is all too often made a reality, not seen. (And yes, there are also fathers who were real victims of false accusations. But not to the extent, as is common.)
I want all who hear of the topic, perhaps the first time, would demand very careful and very to be critical when it comes to the issue of false accusations in abuse cases. Unfortunately, all too often turn out to be just working for the rights of alleged fathers, and children are very destructive actors who share allerleih nonsense in the world. The protection of children are not served by a number such as the spread above 40% in the world, it serves to protect the real perpetrators.
(Note: This text was posted on 07/01/2011 again added to some lines and data - especially at the Berlin study and the subsequent calculation example - so far as the comments below still refer to the old text version)
Links:
Is there an "abuse of the abuse?"
helper Mafia "and" care Stasi "- On the abuse with abuse
0 comments:
Post a Comment