A Länzlein for evangelical songs There's a new blog
, that the relationship between Catholic and evangelical busy and then spits on the John evangelical "
Geklampfe .
I say first with the mole ne, ne, ne, ne, ne
And then
Distinguo! thesis evangelicals music has nothing to do with sacropop!
Biographical Prerequisite: I also was in the youth in the YMCA
confession: I also play guitar
respondeo: evangelicals songs or as John says, "YMCA Geklampfe" is to a particular situation-bound feature music, is similar to a march that the IMSA or the military has a function ("now is time to the beat, you suckers!") and yes even with the Gregorian chant, which belongs to the situation of the show (and the Office) and as not in the concert hall.
The situation of the evangelical song good is the Bible class, the Certificate of preaching and worship event (and this number is excessive, the normal evangelical church - Oh Your wedding Lutherans forgive me!). In this situation, these songs provide follow-up assessment and re-telling of biblical texts, personal and group-specific beliefs, like the call to conversion / decision to the audience and some traces of prayers. All'dies is appropriate in the situation.
All this is doing to the music in Rüchkgriff such Bund / Scout songs, and recently on spirituals / gospel and folk music / the folk. All this is reasonable - Whether a ballad of King David or of mercenaries is told musically have a damn blog, and even some folk songs in the title, such as in Herder, songs of nations for the first time in Germany
beschriebenes .
Ganz anders im Sakropop.
Da fehlt erstens der Rückgriff auf die biblischen Texte fast vollständig, stattdessen findet sich meist eine Aneinanderreihung von Gefühlsphrasen und möglichst unklaren Metaphern in oft (ich nehme an bewußt, "is ja schließlich Lyrik, ej!") unkorrekter Grammatik.
Da ist zweitens, die Musik nur scheinbar simpel und wird insbesondere durch vollständig überflüssige Synkopen und Triolen gebrochen. Oft ist sie orientiert an etwas, was die Komponisten wohl für jazzy oder gar für modern hielten.
Und drittens soll dies ganze ja gerade, in der Messe also in der Gegenwart Gottes dargeboten werden. Nur found between situation and music can not stop intersection.
Summary: further complains of Peter Jansen's unhappy memory (still rip) and his little friends, but let me Evangelicals alone!
View: For Gospel and Southern Music:
Scipio, you pick!